They put too much stock into their older riders and neglected developing younger talent for too long of a period to maintain top dog status. Now they have Simon, Griffin, Niels, Breana, Manchild, Hakeem, Aikens but it was too little too late in terms of being at the top of the mountain in skateboarding. For years the stigma was that getting on Girl specifically was almost impossible. In their heyday I guess that created this “cool”, “elite” stigma, but in the end it destroyed their future. You can’t just lack to develop riders for years while letting existing riders to do virtually nothing, and expect it to turn out well. There’s quite a few guys now who are huge or at least decently successful they had the chance to have that they turned down (I.e Jamie Foy).
~2012-ish they put all their stock into guys like Koston, Guy, Mike Mo, Malto, CK, Eldridge, MJ, Hsu etc, and it just worked out poorly. A lot of their guys left, a lot of them got hurt, and we know what happened to CK.
I think it’s largely their own fault, but they had some shitty luck too.